Electric Review

Culture & Criticism Since 2003

Bob Dylan 1970 Extends the Idea of the Bootleg Series

BOB DYLAN LIVE 1970. 50th Anniversary Collection. Bob Dylan (featuring George Harrison). Columbia Legacy. Produced for release by Jeff Rosen and Steve Berkowitz. Sessions originally produced for Columbia by Bob Johnston.

“Bob Dylan released Self Portrait and New Morning in 1970, two albums from an artistic evolution that continues to this day. Bob Dylan 1970 chronicles the road that led to their completion. This collection of recording sessions between March 3 and August 12, 1970 features three-and-a-half hours of unreleased outtakes that recount the development of those two albums. “Life isn’t about finding yourself or finding anything,” noted a contemporary Dylan in the recent film Rolling Thunder Revue: A Bob Dylan Story by Martin Scorsese. “Life is about creating yourself.” What’s evident in these tracks is the immense satisfaction he derives from the act of creation. The multiple versions of the same song often vary in tempo, arrangement and vocal style – he was a sketch artist even in the recording studio…”     

Michael Simmons in the liner notes to Bob Dylan 1970
Cover courtesy of Columbia/Legacy

In August 1971, Bob Dylan returned to the stage following a four-year hiatus, returning to perform with Beatles’ guitarist George Harrison at Madison Square Garden in the famed “Concert for Bangladesh.” The event marked a significant turning point in Dylan’s career, as this post-motorcycle-accident appearance featured an acoustic set augmented by Harrison’s gentle guitar swirls.

The collection takes us back 50 years to the historic collaborations between these two musicians that were framed around Dylan’s Self Portrait and New Morning sessions. A segment of this particular collection is comprised of outtakes from the work Harrison and Dylan did together, and the songs remain illuminating on a multiplicity of levels. Nonetheless, since these outtakes originate from the same period as the Another Self Portrait and Travelin’ Thru volumes, some are likely to ask – “What’s the point? What’s really new here?”

Ultimately, this collection compels because it shows the creative process in motion, allowing us to enter the studio alongside Dylan and Harrison to see exactly how songs are pieced together and how the final production is reached. Listeners should view this record as a living extension of Another Self Portrait. Accordingly, there’s a lot to digest here – like multiple takes of  classics like “If Not For You” and “Went To See Gypsy,” in addition to sweet covers of well-known pop hits that inspired both Dylan and Harrison (“Thirsty Boots;” “Universal Soldier;” “Cupid;” ”I Met Him On A Sunday”).

But for my money, the centerpiece of the set is found in the version of “Gates Of Eden” (Take 1; Disc 2). This performance spotlights the boundless dimensions of the poem juxtaposed with Dylan’s psyche 6 years after he wrote the piece. The intricate interplay between Dylan’s voice and Harrison’s guitar work captivates, commanding multiple rewinds. This is the very playing Harrison displayed on the best of those Beatles’ albums, and when paired with Dylan’s 1970s’ voice, the result is truly stunning. Other standout tracks include “Alligator Man;” “Spanish Is the Loving Tongue;” the haunting “Tomorrow Is A Long Time;” “Yesterday;” and Sign On The Window” from New Morning.

With 74 songs on three discs, there’s a huge amount of music here that will thrill and intrigue dedicated listeners. Still, some might be disappointed that there are no big ‘surprise’ songs and no monumental discoveries. And they will have missed the point entirely. In sum, this record extends and helps define the idea of the famed Bootleg Series (even though this particular collection is not part of that series), shedding light on what the old art of bootlegging was all about. The little hidden gems that fill up the bellies of these records are what those 1960s music pirates were after when they were secretly taping Dylan’s every utterance.

In the end, listeners should not lose sight of the fact that the aforementioned Bootleg Series isn’t all about major discoveries. Rather, the underlying point is to understand the reason why so many fans want to own all of the outtakes from 60 years worth of recording sessions: There’s gold in these in half songs; and there’s a point of illumination that comes in watching an artist ply his craft at the canvas.

When you finally reach the last track of Dylan 1970, you’ll likely ask: “Just what else does Columbia have in those vaults that we haven’t heard?” And that question, then, serves as further testament to the vast reach of  Bob Dylan’s work as we bare witness to one of the most complex and impactful artists to appear in the last 200 years.

by John Aiello


Talk to Rat:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on March 17, 2021 by in 2021, In the Spotlight, March 2021, Rat On Music and tagged , , .
In accordance with FTC Guidelines on blogging and product reviews, The Electric Review discloses that the books, records, DVDS and other products reviewed are submitted to us by publishers, record labels, publicity firms, artists, manufacturers and creators free of charge. The Electric Review further states that these entities and individuals submit materials to us of their own volition and understand that the submission of material is for discretionary consideration by the Editor and is not to be construed as to be in ‘exchange’ for a review.
The Electric Review does not serve as a ‘for-hire’ advertising vehicle and the submission of material for review creates no agreement either express or implicit requiring us to provide comment on a book, record, film, product or event. In sum, The Electric Review accepts no payment for the publication of a review. Instead, commentary is published as a free public service with reviews based solely on merit and the lasting classroom or cultural value of a given work: this compendium of essays meant to serve as an electronic library and on-going teaching resource surveying the 21st-century landscape.
Website copyright: John Aiello & The Electric Review. All rights reserved.
Violations of this notice are subject to sanction under United States Code: Title 17.
Reproduction of material from any Electric Review pages without the written permission of John Aiello or the named author is strictly prohibited.
%d bloggers like this: